NEW! Nerd Leagues is now on iOS and Android Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Card Search

30 cards
Cards where it is tagged “secretly choose” Tag: secretly choose
Wheel of Misfortune {2}{R}
Sorcery

Each player secretly chooses a number 0 or greater, then all players reveal those numbers simultaneously and determine the highest and lowest numbers revealed this way. Wheel of Misfortune deals damage equal to the highest number to each player who chose that number. Each player who didn't choose the lowest number discards their hand, then draws seven cards.

CMR · Rare · $2.49
Prisoner's Dilemma {3}{R}{R}
Sorcery

Each opponent secretly chooses silence or snitch, then the choices are revealed. If each opponent chose silence, Prisoner's Dilemma deals 4 damage to each of them. If each opponent chose snitch, Prisoner's Dilemma deals 8 damage to each of them. Otherwise, Prisoner's Dilemma deals 12 damage to each opponent who chose silence.

Flashback {5}{R}{R}

MKC · Rare · $6.21
Mob Verdict {2}{R}{R}
Sorcery

Secret council — Each player secretly votes for another player, then those votes are revealed. For each vote an opponent received, Mob Verdict deals 2 damage to that player and each creature that player controls. For each vote you received, draw a card.

MKC · Rare · $0.40
Círdan the Shipwright {3}{G}{U}
Legendary Creature — Elf Noble

Vigilance

Secret council — Whenever Círdan enters or attacks, each player secretly votes for a player, then those votes are revealed. Each player draws a card for each vote they received. Each player who received no votes may put a permanent card from their hand onto the battlefield.

3/4 LTC · Rare · $0.31
Trap the Trespassers {2}{U}
Instant

Secret council — Each player secretly votes for a creature you don't control, then those votes are revealed. For each creature with one or more votes, put that many stun counters on it, then tap it. (If a permanent with a stun counter would become untapped, remove one from it instead.)

LTC · Rare · $0.24
Elrond of the White Council {3}{G}{U}
Legendary Creature — Elf Noble

Secret council — When Elrond enters, each player secretly votes for fellowship or aid, then those votes are revealed. For each fellowship vote, the voter chooses a creature they control. You gain control of each creature chosen this way, and they gain "This creature can't attack its owner." Then for each aid vote, put a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control.

3/3 LTC · Rare · $0.27
Stalking Leonin {2}{W}
Creature — Cat Archer

When this creature enters, secretly choose an opponent.

Reveal the player you chose: Exile target creature that's attacking you if it's controlled by the chosen player. Activate only once.

3/3 MKC · Rare · $0.30
Truth or Consequences {2}{U}{R}
Sorcery

Secret council — Each player secretly votes for truth or consequences, then those votes are revealed. You draw cards equal to the number of truth votes. Then choose an opponent at random. Truth or Consequences deals 3 damage to that player for each consequences vote.

WHO · Uncommon · $0.34
Vault 11: Voter's Dilemma {2}{W}{B}
Enchantment — Saga

(As this Saga enters and after your draw step, add a lore counter. Sacrifice after III.)

I — For each opponent, you create a 1/1 white Human Soldier creature token.

II, III — Each player secretly votes for up to one creature, then those votes are revealed. If no creature got votes, each player draws a card. Otherwise, destroy each creature with the most votes or tied for most votes.

PIP · Rare · $0.26
Goblin Game {5}{R}{R}
Sorcery

Each player hides at least one item, then all players reveal them simultaneously. Each player loses life equal to the number of items they revealed. The player who revealed the fewest items then loses half their life, rounded up. If two or more players are tied for fewest, each loses half their life, rounded up.

PLS · Rare · $1.32
Malik, Grim Manipulator {2}{R}{W}{B}
Legendary Creature — Human Rogue

When Malik, Grim Manipulator enters, you and target opponent each secretly choose a creature that player controls. Then those choices are revealed, and that player sacrifices those creatures.

Whenever an opponent sacrifices a creature, you create a Treasure token.

4/3 SLX · Mythic · $5.12
The Toymaker's Trap {2}{B}
Enchantment

At the beginning of your upkeep, secretly choose a number between 1 and 5 that hasn't been chosen. If you do, an opponent guesses which number you chose, then you reveal the number you chose. If they guessed wrong, they lose life equal to the number they guessed and you draw a card. If they guessed right, sacrifice this enchantment.

WHO · Rare · $0.24
Expert-Level Safe {2}
Artifact

When this artifact enters, exile the top two cards of your library face down.

{1}, {T}: You and target opponent each secretly choose 1, 2, or 3. Then those choices are revealed. If they match, sacrifice this artifact and put all cards exiled with it into their owners' hands. Otherwise, exile the top card of your library face down.

PIP · Uncommon · $0.15
Emissary of Grudges {5}{R}
Creature — Efreet

Flying, haste

As this creature enters, secretly choose an opponent.

Reveal the player you chose: Choose new targets for target spell or ability if it's controlled by the chosen player and if it targets you or a permanent you control. Activate only once.

6/5 C18 · Rare · $0.38
Call to the Void {4}{B}
Sorcery

Each player secretly chooses a creature they control and a creature they don't control. Then those choices are revealed. Destroy each creature chosen this way.

CLB · Rare · $0.18
Itazura, Lingering Wick {2}{U}{R}
Legendary Creature — Spirit

At the beginning of your upkeep, exile the top three cards of your library. Each opponent secretly chooses a number 0 or greater. Then those numbers are revealed. Choose an opponent with the highest number. Itazura deals that much damage to them, then they may cast a spell from among those cards without paying its mana cost. You put a card from among them that wasn't cast this way into your hand.

1/5 MBC · Rare · $7.84
A Killer Among Us {4}{G}
Enchantment

When this enchantment enters, create a 1/1 white Human creature token, a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token, and a 1/1 red Goblin creature token. Then secretly choose Human, Merfolk, or Goblin.

Sacrifice this enchantment, Reveal the creature type you chose: If target attacking creature token is the chosen type, put three +1/+1 counters on it and it gains deathtouch until end of turn.

MKM · Uncommon · $0.14
Guardian Archon {4}{W}{W}
Creature — Archon

Flying

As this creature enters, secretly choose an opponent.

Reveal the player you chose: You and target permanent you control each gain protection from the chosen player until end of turn. Activate only once.

5/5 C21 · Rare · $0.23
Menacing Ogre {3}{R}{R}
Creature — Ogre

Trample, haste

When this creature enters, each player secretly chooses a number. Then those numbers are revealed. Each player with the highest number loses that much life. If you are one of those players, put two +1/+1 counters on this creature.

3/3 HOP · Rare · $0.20
Buzzing Whack-a-Doodle {4}
Artifact

As this artifact enters, you and an opponent each secretly choose Whack or Doodle. Then those choices are revealed. If the choices match, this artifact has that ability. Otherwise, it has Buzz.

• Whack — {T}: Target player loses 2 life.

• Doodle — {T}: You gain 3 life.

• Buzz — {2}, {T}: Draw a card.

UST · Uncommon · $0.25
Hangman {B}
Creature — Human Villain

As this creature enters, secretly note a word with six to eight letters.

{1}: Target player who doesn't control this creature guesses the noted word or an unguessed letter in that word. If they guess wrong, put a +1/+1 counter on this creature. Any player may activate this ability.

When a player guesses the noted word or all of its letters, sacrifice this creature.

1/1 UST · Rare · $0.33
Identify the Culprit {W}
Sorcery

Secretly choose a creature target opponent controls. Then, that player guesses which creature it is. Reveal the chosen creature. If they guessed incorrectly, exile the creature you chose. Otherwise, return Identify the Culprit to its owner's hand and you can't cast it again this turn.

UNK · Uncommon
Life at Stake {B}
Instant

You and target creature's controller each secretly choose a number 0 or greater. Then, reveal the chosen numbers. If your number was highest or tied for the highest, exile that creature. Each player who chose the highest number loses that much life.

UNK · Common
Mana Conference
Land

When Mana Conference enters the battlefield, each player secretly chooses a basic land type, then those choices are revealed. Mana Conference gains each basic land type that received at least one vote. (Basic land types are Plains, Island, Swamp, Mountain, and Forest.)

UNK · Uncommon · $40.98
Ominous Lockbox {1}{U}
Artifact — Clue

As Ominous Lockbox enters, secretly choose a number between 1 and 20.

When an opponent casts a spell with mana value equal to the chosen number, sacrifice Ominous Lockbox. If you do, copy that spell, and you may choose new targets for the copy.

{2}, Sacrifice Ominous Lockbox: Draw a card.

YMKM · Rare
Power Level Analyzer {3}
Artifact Creature — Construct

As Power Level Analyzer enters the battlefield, you and target opponent each secretly choose a number between 1 and 10, then reveal. Power Level Analyzer enters with a number of +1/+1 counters equal to the distance between the two numbers. If both players chose the same number, put seven +1/+1 counters on Power Level Analyzer instead.

0/0 UNK · Uncommon · $14.99
Retto, Family Racer {1}{G}
Legendary Creature — Human Pilot

Before the game begins, if this is your commander or in your deck, secretly write down the names of five creature cards to be part of your family.

As members of your family enters, you may say "Nothing is stronger than family" and reveal its name from your list. That creature enters with two +1/+1 counters on it.

2/2 UNK · Rare
Six-y Beast {3}{R}
Creature — Beast

As this creature enters, you secretly put six or fewer +1/+1 counters on it, then an opponent guesses the number of counters. If that player guesses right, sacrifice this creature after it enters.

0/0 UND · Uncommon · $0.10
Speedbrood Stalker {3}{B}{B}
Creature — Insect Assassin

Flying, Lifelink

When this creature enters, choose target opponent. Secretly choose a creature or planeswalker that player controls. That player sacrifices a creature or planeswalker of their choice, then sacrifices the chosen permanent.

3/4 YDFT · Mythic
The Good Time Sleuth {3}{W}{B}
Legendary Creature — Human?

When The Good Time Sleuth enters, exile the top card of your library and each nontoken creature you control in a face-down pile, shuffle that pile, then manifest those cards. Then create a Blood token for each face-down creature you control. Those creature gain "Sacrifice a Blood: Turn this creature face up." Secretly choose one of them. As that creature is turned face up, reveal the choice and it becomes a 5/5 black Demon.