NEW! Nerd Leagues is now on iOS and Android Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Turn Every Game Into Data

Nerd Leagues tracks your Commander win rates, ELO, and deck performance — free. See who really runs your pod.

Track Your Games Free

Toph, the First Metalbender Commander Deck: Landfall Without Playing Lands

Deck Tech Commander
Toph, the First Metalbender
Toph, the First Metalbender · Art by Eilene Cherie

Toph, the First Metalbender is the Naya legend (red, green and white) from Avatar: The Last Airbender that reads like a rules puzzle and plays like a landfall deck with the brakes cut. This Toph, the First Metalbender commander deck is our bracket 3 build: we started from a typical list and made nine swaps we can defend, and the audit is linked so you can check the number yourself. It is the second Avatar legend we have built, after Fire Lord Azula, and the stranger of the two.

For {1}{R}{G}{W} you get a four-mana body with two abilities. Nontoken artifacts you control are lands in addition to their other types, and at the beginning of your end step you earthbend 2. Earthbend is the set's keyword action: a land you control becomes a 0/0 creature with haste that is still a land, it gets that many +1/+1 counters, and if it dies or is exiled it returns to the battlefield tapped.

Why "artifacts are lands" is the whole deck

Static abilities apply the moment a permanent enters, so when you cast Sol Ring with Toph on the table it enters as a land, and every landfall ability you control fires (landfall means "whenever a land you control enters"). Lotus Cobra adds a mana, Scute Swarm makes an Insect, Tireless Provisioner makes a Treasure, Tannuk, Memorial Ensign pings the table. A free Mishra's Bauble is a landfall trigger that also replaces itself with a card, and with Moraug, Fury of Akoum out, casting it in a main phase is an extra combat for zero mana. Tokens are the exception: a Treasure is a token, so Toph doesn't make it a land.

The reminder text says those artifacts don't gain the ability to tap for mana just from being lands. Four cards in the deck get around that. Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth makes every land a Forest, and the Forest type carries its own "{T}: Add {G}", so your Bauble and your Lightning Greaves tap for green the turn they land (noncreature artifacts have no summoning sickness). Dryad of the Ilysian Grove gives your lands every basic land type, which is the same trick in all five colors. Chromatic Lantern and Great Divide Guide both give lands "{T}: Add one mana of any color", and under Toph that means every nontoken artifact you control.

Earthbent lands are sticky. "When it dies or is exiled, return it to the battlefield tapped" is part of every earthbend, so a land Toph animated at your end step can be sacrificed to Zuran Orb, Sylvan Safekeeper, Crop Rotation, Cycle of Renewal or Greater Good and it comes straight back, which is another landfall trigger. It also means Swords to Plowshares or Path to Exile aimed at your 8/8 land just hands you a tapped land. Amulet of Vigor untaps it on the way in.

Terra Eternal is the card that makes the engine safe. All lands have indestructible, and under Toph "all lands" includes your mana rocks (artifacts that tap for mana), your Equipment and every animated land. A damage sweeper or a destroy-all-creatures spell leaves the land army standing and takes only the creatures that were never lands.

Toph, the First Metalbender
Terra Eternal
Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth
Terrasymbiosis

The list

The full deck page is Toph, the First Metalbender Bracket 3, and the bracket audit puts it at bracket 3 with one Game Changer, Crop Rotation. Game Changers are the cards the Commander bracket system singles out as too strong for a precon table; bracket 3 allows up to three of them, and our brackets guide covers the rest of the rules. The list below has a copy button if you want it in your own builder.

Toph, the First Metalbender Bracket 3 (EDH)

How a game goes

Turns one through three are about landing Toph on turn three. Exploration, Sol Ring, Arcane Signet, Nature's Lore and Three Visits all get there. Lotus Cobra on turn two gets there off any third land, with mana to spare if that land is a true fetchland like Wooded Foothills (a land you sacrifice to search up another, untapped, which is two landfall triggers). Cast cheap artifacts before her only if you have to: every one you hold until she has resolved is a landfall trigger you bank.

Once she is out, your end step gives you a 2/2 land with haste. The Earth Crystal doubles the counters, so it is a 4/4, and Terrasymbiosis lets you draw cards equal to the counters placed, once per turn. Two details matter. The draw is a "may" and you only get one per turn, so decline it on a small trigger (a proliferate, a Bumi, Eclectic Earthbender attack) and take it on the biggest one. And the once-per-turn clock counts every turn, yours or theirs, so holding Earthshape for an opponent's end step is earthbend 3 and three cards on their turn, then Toph's trigger draws again on yours.

The win is a wide board of land creatures with too much text on them. Toph, Greatest Earthbender gives land creatures double strike. Earthbending Student gives them vigilance, so they attack and still tap for mana afterwards. Avatar Kyoshi, Earthbender earthbends 8 at the beginning of each of your combats and then untaps that land, so the sequence is to tap a land for mana in your first main phase, spend it, and point Kyoshi at that same land: it untaps and swings as an 8/8 with haste. Bumi, Unleashed connecting untaps all your lands (rocks included) and gives you a second combat for land creatures only. Scute Swarm copies itself on every landfall once you control six lands, and with artifacts counted that is usually turn five.

Annie Joins Up costs the same as Toph and makes each triggered ability of your legendary creatures trigger an additional time. Toph earthbends twice at your end step, Moraug's extra combat becomes two, and Tannuk, Memorial Ensign triggers twice for every land, which is 2 damage to each opponent per land, with the first land each turn also drawing a card. Evolution Sage turns every landfall into a proliferate (one more of each kind of counter already on whatever you choose), which grows every animated land, adds an experience counter for Toph, Earthbending Master (a counter you keep as a player, which sets how big her attack-trigger earthbend is), and adds a lore counter to The Legend of Kyoshi. That Saga, an enchantment that normally advances one chapter per turn, then flips a turn early into the back face that gives your lands hexproof and trample.

Annie Joins Up
Avatar Kyoshi, Earthbender
Toph, Greatest Earthbender
Bumi, Unleashed

Mistakes the deck invites

Do not earthbend an Equipment. Sword of the Animist and Lightning Greaves are lands under Toph, so they are legal targets, but an Equipment that becomes a creature can't stay attached to anything (rule 301.5c) and falls off. Animate a mana rock or a real land instead; an earthbent Sol Ring still taps for {C}{C} and swings for 2.

Hour of Revelation destroys all nonland permanents. Under Toph your artifacts are lands and live, and so do your animated lands, but your enchantments and any creature that isn't a land do not, so Terrasymbiosis, Bitter Work, Terra Eternal and Toph herself go with it (Ashaya, Soul of the Wild changes that by making your nontoken creatures Forests). The bigger exception is Mycosynth Lattice, which makes every permanent an artifact: with Toph out, every nontoken permanent you control is then a land, and Hour of Revelation clears your opponents' boards and your own tokens while leaving the rest of yours. Lattice cuts both ways. Without Terra Eternal in play it turns an opponent's Vandalblast cast overloaded (paid for its bigger cost, so it destroys every artifact they don't control) into land destruction aimed at you, so cast Terra Eternal first and Lattice second.

Terra Eternal does not stop exile. A Farewell set to artifacts and creatures takes every artifact and creature you never earthbent, your plain lands stay, and the animated lands come back tapped. So the lands you spend your other earthbends on (Ba Sing Se, Bitter Work, Rockalanche) should be the ones you would miss most, and Earthshape covers one more at instant speed.

What we changed from the usual list

The typical Toph list is a fine starting point and an unfinished deck. These are the nine swaps and the reason for each.

  • Badgermole out, Titania, Protector of Argoth in. Five mana for earthbend 2 and trample was the weakest earthbender in the pile. Titania makes a 5/3 every time one of your lands hits the graveyard, and this deck sacrifices lands constantly: Zuran Orb, Sylvan Safekeeper, Crop Rotation, Cycle of Renewal, fetchlands, Krosan Verge, Greater Good. Under Toph a sacrificed Mishra's Bauble or Ichor Wellspring is a land too, so even those make Elementals.
  • Earthbending Lesson out, Ancient Greenwarden in. A four-mana sorcery that earthbends once, against a creature that doubles every landfall trigger you control, including the ones from casting artifacts, and lets you replay fetchlands and Krosan Verge from the graveyard. Stack it with Annie Joins Up and one Mishra's Bauble is three Tannuk, Memorial Ensign triggers (each effect adds one trigger; they don't multiply).
  • Bender's Waterskin out, Sword of the Animist in. Both are artifacts, so both are lands and landfall triggers under Toph. The Sword costs one less and, on an earthbent land that already has haste, fetches a basic every time it attacks, which is a landfall trigger per attack. The Waterskin was a rock that untapped on other players' turns and nothing more.
  • The Stasis Coffin out, Greater Good in. The Coffin is a one-shot shield that exiles itself. Greater Good sacrifices an animated land for cards equal to its power (then you discard three), and the land returns tapped for another landfall trigger. When someone exiles your 8/8 land it was coming back anyway; sacrificing it in response turns the eight counters you were about to lose into eight cards.
  • Liquimetal Coating out, Generous Gift in. Coating needs a second card (Haywire Mite or Origin of Metalbending) before it removes anything, and Liquimetal Torque already covers the artifact-making trick while tapping for mana. Gift answers any permanent at instant speed.
  • Secret Tunnel out, Krosan Verge in. Verge is colorless too and enters tapped, so this is not a fixing swap on its face. It is about what Verge turns into: for {2} it fetches a Forest card and a Plains card, typed duals included (nonbasic lands with basic land types printed on them, like Temple Garden and Canopy Vista), which is two colored sources, two landfall triggers and a Titania Elemental, and Greenwarden lets you play it again from the graveyard. We give up an unblockable earthbend target to do it.
  • Swiftfoot Boots out, Exploration in. A second pair of boots against an extra land drop every turn, which is more earthbend targets and more landfall. Lightning Greaves stays to protect Toph.
  • Expedition Map out, Three Visits in. Map spends three mana to put one land in your hand. Three Visits spends two to put a typed dual like Stomping Ground onto the battlefield, untapped if you pay its 2 life, which saves the land drop and triggers landfall the turn you cast it.
  • A basic Forest out, Boseiju, Who Endures in. Free, and its channel cost (discard it from hand to destroy an artifact, enchantment or nonbasic land) drops by one for each legendary creature you control, which is about half the creatures in this deck.

Kept on purpose: Mycosynth Lattice for the Hour of Revelation line and because with Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth out it makes every nontoken permanent you control tap for {G}, summoning-sick creatures aside; Zuran Orb as a free sacrifice outlet for animated lands; and Rumble Arena, which has vigilance printed on it for the day it gets earthbent.

Mulligans

Toph is in the command zone, so the question is what the hand gives her. Keep three lands plus a cheap artifact or a two-mana ramp spell. A hand with no artifacts gives her nothing to turn into landfall for the first few turns, and a hand of rocks with one land can't cast her on turn three. Mulligan two lands and an eight-mana card even when the eight-mana card is Avatar Kyoshi, Earthbender; the deck draws plenty once it is running and nothing before that.

If you build it, record the games. Deck ratings on Nerd Leagues move on every result, so after ten pods you know whether the land army actually closes or only looks like it should. The game log keeps a record for the deck as well as for you.


Comments

Join the conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep Reading

Turn Every Game Into Data

Nerd Leagues tracks your Commander win rates, ELO, and deck performance — free. See who really runs your pod.

Track Your Games Free