NEW! Nerd Leagues is now on iOS and Android Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

How Good Are You, Really?

Nerd Leagues gives every player and deck a competitive ELO rating that updates after every game. Climb the rankings.

Get Your Rating

The Best Token Makers in Commander, Color by Color: What Each One Is Actually For

Strategy Commander
Tendershoot Dryad
Tendershoot Dryad · Art by Evyn Fong

Bitterblossom makes one Faerie a round. Tendershoot Dryad makes four. Both trigger at the beginning of an upkeep, but Bitterblossom says your upkeep and the Dryad says each upkeep, and in a four-player Commander pod that one word is the difference between a token every time you untap and a token every time anyone does. That is the lens for this list of the best token makers in Commander: how each card behaves with three opponents at the table, not one.

The picks are sorted by color. Inside each color, every entry is tagged with the job it does: engine (tokens every turn), burst (many at once), on-attack (bodies that arrive swinging), insurance (tokens at instant speed or when something dies) or value (Treasure, a token you sacrifice for one mana of any color, and other tokens that are not creatures). Each color also gets a line on the job it cannot fill. The post joins our color-by-color series and is built like the best ramp by color and the best removal by color: the one thing each card is for, and one line of play.

White: bodies that arrive attacking

Two of white's best token makers put their tokens onto the battlefield already attacking. A token that enters attacking was never declared as an attacker, so it pays no Ghostly Prison tax and triggers none of the "whenever a creature attacks" abilities on either side of the table. White's gap is value tokens: its best Treasure maker is Smothering Tithe, which is on the official Game Changers list (the cards that push a deck up the power brackets), and we leave it out so no pick here is a Game Changer.

  • Adeline, Resplendent Cathar ({1}{W}{W}), on-attack. Job: a 1/1 Human aimed at each opponent every time you attack, on a body whose power is the number of creatures you control. Line of play: attack with Adeline alone on turn four and three Humans arrive, each attacking a different player. With just those four creatures she is a 4/4, one bigger for every creature you kept home, so point her at the player least able to block a 4/4.
  • Hero of Bladehold ({2}{W}{W}), on-attack. Job: two attacking 1/1 Soldiers and battle cry (+1/+0 to each other attacking creature) every combat. Line of play: both are attack triggers and you choose their order, so let the Soldiers resolve first and battle cry pumps them too. She needs to live one turn cycle, so cast her when the removal-heavy player is tapped out.
  • Elspeth, Sun's Champion ({4}{W}{W}), engine. Job: three 1/1 Soldiers a turn, and a board wipe that spares them. Line of play: use the +1 the turn she lands so she has blockers. Save the -3 (destroy all creatures with power 4 or greater) for the turn the table's big threats are out and your board is still 1/1s, and it is a one-sided wrath (a spell that destroys every creature).
  • Secure the Wastes ({X}{W}, instant), insurance. Job: X 1/1 Warriors at instant speed. Line of play: never cast it in response to a wrath, because the tokens would die to it. Hold it until the wrath has resolved, then cast it in the end step of the player whose turn comes right before yours. You untap with an army that no sorcery-speed answer has had a chance at.
  • Ocelot Pride ({W}), engine. Job: a 1/1 Cat at your end step on any turn you gained life, and once you control ten permanents (the city's blessing), a copy of every token that entered this turn. Line of play: it has lifelink (damage it deals also gains you that much life), so any damage it deals, to a player or to a blocker, turns it on, and first strike means it usually deals that damage before the blocker can kill it. With the blessing, on a turn it connects alongside Hero, your end step gives you the Cat plus copies of the Cat and both Soldiers.
Adeline, Resplendent Cathar
Hero of Bladehold
Elspeth, Sun's Champion
Secure the Wastes
Ocelot Pride

Blue: tokens for casting spells

Blue does not make tokens for free. Its best makers pay you for casting the spells a blue deck was going to cast anyway. Blue's gaps are on-attack and value: nothing in the color that arrives swinging is worth a slot, and neither are its Treasure makers.

  • Talrand, Sky Summoner ({2}{U}{U}), engine. Job: a 2/2 flying Drake for every instant or sorcery you cast. Line of play: in a pod, holding a counterspell is also holding a Drake, so a Talrand deck should counter the first real threat rather than wait for the perfect one. The Drake arrives either way.
  • Murmuring Mystic ({3}{U}), engine. Job: the same trigger on a second body, making 1/1 flying Bird Illusions. Line of play: run both. Mystic is not legendary, so it is the one to copy with Rite of Replication, and the copies survive the legend rule (control two legendary permanents with the same name and you keep only one).
  • Shark Typhoon ({5}{U}), insurance. Job: an X/X flying Shark for every noncreature spell, where X is the spell's mana value (the total mana in its cost, counting X), or cycle it (discard it for {X}{1}{U} to draw a card) and get an X/X Shark at instant speed. Line of play: the cycling mode is the real card. Cycle it in an opponent's end step and the Shark comes from an ability, not a spell, so a counterspell cannot stop it.
  • Rite of Replication ({2}{U}{U}, kicker {5}), burst. Job: one copy of a creature, or five copies if you pay the kicker (an optional extra cost) for nine mana in total, and the creature does not have to be yours. Line of play: pick a nonlegendary creature with an enters-the-battlefield trigger. Five copies of Grave Titan is ten Zombies on top of five Titans. Copies of a legendary creature die to the legend rule and leave you with one.
  • Sai, Master Thopterist ({2}{U}), engine. Job: a 1/1 flying Thopter for every artifact spell you cast. Line of play: Sol Ring is a Thopter. Late in the game, {1}{U} and two artifacts to draw a card turns the mana rocks (artifacts that tap for mana) you no longer need into cards.

Black: tokens that pay in life or in bodies

Black's gaps are insurance and on-attack: it has no instant-speed token maker worth running, and even Grave Titan's Zombies arrive untapped rather than attacking, so a black army is rebuilt a turn at a time. Its best value tokens come from death, with Pitiless Plunderer making a Treasure whenever another creature you control dies, which makes it a sacrifice deck's card rather than this list's.

  • Bitterblossom ({1}{B}), engine. Job: a 1/1 flying Faerie Rogue every one of your upkeeps, for 1 life each. Line of play: it is a clock on you as much as an engine. Cast on turn two, it has made six fliers by turn eight, and a sacrifice outlet (a permanent that lets you sacrifice creatures for an effect) turns the life you paid into something.
  • Grave Titan ({4}{B}{B}), burst. Job: two 2/2 Zombies when it enters and two more every time it attacks, on a 6/6 body with deathtouch (any damage it deals is lethal). Line of play: the two Zombies from entering stay even if the Titan dies to the first removal spell, so it is never a dead six mana. If it survives to attack once, one card has made four Zombies, and fourteen power sits on the table counting the Titan.
  • Ophiomancer ({2}{B}), engine. Job: a 1/1 deathtouch Snake at the beginning of each upkeep, if you control no Snakes. Line of play: without a sacrifice outlet it is a free deathtouch blocker that comes back. With one, it is four Snakes a round, because the trigger checks on every player's upkeep.
  • Endrek Sahr, Master Breeder ({4}{B}), engine. Job: 1/1 Thrulls equal to the mana value of every creature spell you cast. Line of play: he sacrifices himself when you control seven or more Thrulls, so keep your Thrull count plus the next creature's mana value at six or fewer, sacrificing Thrulls first if you have an outlet. Or cast the big creature anyway and keep every Thrull when he goes.
  • Liliana, Dreadhorde General ({4}{B}{B}), engine. Job: a 2/2 Zombie every turn and a card every time a creature you control dies. Line of play: her -4 makes each player sacrifice two creatures of their choice, so opponents give up their worst two. Fire it at a table where someone has one or two creatures, where it strips them, and not into a wide board, where it does not. You sacrifice two tokens and draw two cards either way.
Bitterblossom
Grave Titan
Ophiomancer
Endrek Sahr, Master Breeder
Liliana, Dreadhorde General

Red: Goblins, and Treasure

Red's gap is insurance. Apart from Krenko, Mob Boss's tap and the Elementals Young Pyromancer makes off your instants, red makes its bodies on its own turn, so it rebuilds after a wrath a turn at a time.

  • Krenko, Mob Boss ({2}{R}{R}), engine. Job: doubles your Goblins every time he taps. Line of play: his ability is {T} with no sorcery-speed restriction, so he can tap at instant speed once he has been under your control since your most recent turn began. Two uses matter. Tapping in response to the removal spell aimed at him gets one last activation. Tapping in the end step of the player before you makes Goblins that skip a round of sorcery-speed wraths and can attack right away.
  • Siege-Gang Commander ({3}{R}{R}), burst. Job: four bodies for five mana and a way to turn them into damage. Line of play: {1}{R} and a Goblin for 2 damage to any target. When a wrath is on the stack, sacrifice as many Goblins as your open mana pays for at the face of the player who cast it. Bodies that were about to die anyway become direct damage.
  • Legion Warboss ({2}{R}), engine. Job: a 1/1 Goblin with haste (it can attack the turn it arrives) at the beginning of each of your combats, and it has to attack. Line of play: the token must attack if able, but you choose whom. Send it at the player with no untapped creatures, and attack with Warboss alongside it so mentor (a +1/+1 counter on an attacking creature with lesser power) grows it.
  • Young Pyromancer ({1}{R}), engine. Job: a 1/1 Elemental for every instant or sorcery, for two mana. Line of play: next to Talrand in a blue-red deck, every removal spell becomes a ground body and a flier. On its own, cast it the turn before you plan to chain spells, not the turn of.
  • Goldspan Dragon ({3}{R}{R}), value. Job: a Treasure every time it attacks or becomes the target of a spell, and your Treasures tap for two mana instead of one. Line of play: it has haste, so it attacks the turn it lands and pays back two of its five mana at once. Target it with your own instant and you get a Treasure at instant speed.

Green: tokens from lands

Green's token makers care about land drops, so they scale with the ramp you already run. Green's gap is on-attack: nothing in the color that puts bodies into combat is worth a slot, so green token decks lean harder on their finishers.

  • Avenger of Zendikar ({5}{G}{G}), burst. Job: a 0/1 Plant for every land you control, and a +1/+1 counter on every Plant each time a land enters under your control (landfall). Line of play: cast it with your land drop still in hand. Avenger resolves, you play the land, and seven 0/1s are seven 1/2s before any opponent gets a turn to wipe them.
  • Tendershoot Dryad ({4}{G}), engine. Job: a 1/1 Saproling at the beginning of each upkeep, meaning every player's. Line of play: this is the card from the opening paragraph. Four Saprolings a round gets you to ten permanents fast, and with the city's blessing every Saproling is a 3/3. Protect it like a commander.
  • Scute Swarm ({2}{G}), engine. Job: a 1/1 Insect per land drop, and from six lands onward a copy of itself instead. Line of play: every copy has landfall, so with six lands each land you play doubles your Scute Swarms. A fetch land (a land you sacrifice to find another) is two landfall triggers in one turn.
  • Hornet Queen ({4}{G}{G}{G}), burst. Job: five flying deathtouch bodies for seven mana, the best defensive token maker in the game. Line of play: cast it the turn you become the player everyone is attacking. Nobody swings into four deathtouch fliers and their queen, and the turns it buys are the turns the rest of a ramp deck needs to find its finisher.
  • Tireless Provisioner ({2}{G}), value. Job: a Treasure or a Food for every land that enters under your control. Line of play: take Treasure until you can cast your most expensive spells, then Food (two mana and a sacrifice for 3 life) when someone is racing you.
Avenger of Zendikar
Tendershoot Dryad
Scute Swarm
Hornet Queen
Tireless Provisioner

Colorless: tokens any deck can run

Colorless makers go in any deck, and two of the three are insurance: they make their tokens when they die, so a wrath is what switches them on.

  • Myr Battlesphere ({7}), burst. Job: four 1/1 Myr on entry, and a way to turn them into damage without attacking. Line of play: when the Battlesphere attacks, tap X untapped Myr for +X/+0 and X damage to the player it is attacking. The Myr deal their damage without attacking, but they stay tapped through the round, so keep back the ones you need as blockers.
  • Wurmcoil Engine ({6}), insurance. Job: a 6/6 deathtouch lifelink body that leaves a 3/3 deathtouch Wurm and a 3/3 lifelink Wurm when it dies. Line of play: attack into the player with the biggest blocker. Deathtouch kills whatever blocks, lifelink gains you six either way, and a destroy effect only splits it in two.
  • Hangarback Walker ({X}{X}), insurance. Job: a 1/1 flying Thopter for every counter on it when it dies. Line of play: cast it for X=1 on turn two, then pay {1} and tap it once a round for another counter. Do it in the end step of the player before you, so it untaps right away and can block all round. A wrath turns it into fliers.

Doublers and multipliers are not makers

Anointed Procession ({3}{W}), Mondrak, Glory Dominus ({2}{W}{W}), Parallel Lives ({3}{G}) and Doubling Season ({4}{G}) all do the same thing: if an effect would create tokens under your control, it creates twice as many. Mondrak is at least a 4/4 body. The enchantments do nothing on their own, and a deck that leads with one on turn four has spent its turn on nothing. Cast the token maker first and the doubler second, unless the maker is a one-shot. Secure the Wastes, Hornet Queen, Avenger of Zendikar and Grave Titan's entry trigger all make their tokens once, so for those the doubler has to be down first. Two doublers multiply: Procession plus Parallel Lives is four tokens for every one. Doubling Season also doubles counters, so Elspeth enters with eight loyalty and can use her -7 at once, and Hangarback Walker enters with twice X.

Academy Manufactor ({3}) is a multiplier for three kinds of token: every Clue (a token you pay {2} and sacrifice to draw a card), Food or Treasure you would make becomes one of each, so Tireless Provisioner's land drop is three tokens and Goldspan's attack is a Treasure, a Clue and a Food. Second Harvest ({2}{G}{G}, instant) is the one-shot doubler: a copy of every token you control, at instant speed. Cast it in the end step of the turn before yours, once nobody has wiped the board, and untap with double the army.

What the tokens are for

Pick the makers after you pick the plan. A wide attack behind an anthem (a permanent that pumps your whole team) wants on-attack makers and a doubler, and its last step is covered in our finishers by color. A sacrifice deck wants engines that make one body a turn forever, Bitterblossom, Ophiomancer and Legion Warboss, plus Endrek Sahr, whose seven-Thrull limit a sacrifice outlet gets around, and it does not care what the body looks like. A ramp or control deck wants insurance and defensive bodies, Hornet Queen, Secure the Wastes, Hangarback Walker and Wurmcoil Engine, to buy the turns it needs. A spells deck with Talrand, Young Pyromancer and Shark Typhoon gets its tokens as a side effect and should never cast a spell just to make one. If the commander is the token engine, the best tokens commanders ranks them by how they rebuild after a wrath.

To see how other players pair these, the community decks page on Nerd Leagues filters by color and commander and shows each deck's rating and record. Build yours, register it to your league, and deck ELO (a rating that tracks the deck's results separately from yours) will tell you whether forty Saprolings win more games than one Wurmcoil.


Comments

Join the conversation.

Loading comments…

Keep Reading

How Good Are You, Really?

Nerd Leagues gives every player and deck a competitive ELO rating that updates after every game. Climb the rankings.

Get Your Rating